देश की मिटटी की सुगंध--देश की मिटटी से जुडे लोगों का मंच.-- नई तकनीक स्वीकारने के साथ ही विश्व को भारत की वो सौगात /उन महान मूल्यों की रक्षा, हर हाल करना, व्यापक मानवीय आधार है। द्वार खुले रखने का अर्थ अँधानुकरण/प्रदुषण स्वीकारने की बाध्यता नहीं। (निस्संकोच ब्लॉग पर टिप्पणी/अनुसरण/निशुल्क सदस्यता व yugdarpan पर इमेल/चैट करें।संपर्क सूत्र -तिलक संपादक युगदर्पण 07838468776, 9911111611, 9999777358
देश की मिटटी से जुडे लोगों का मंच.-- नई तकनीक स्वीकारने के साथ ही विश्व को भारत की वो सौगात /उन महान मूल्यों की रक्षा, हर हाल करना, व्यापक मानवीय आधार है। द्वार खुले रखने का अर्थ अँधानुकरण/प्रदुषण स्वीकारने की बाध्यता नहीं। (निस्संकोच ब्लॉग पर टिप्पणी/अनुसरण/निशुल्क सदस्यता व yugdarpan पर इमेल/चैट करें।संपर्क सूत्र -तिलक संपादक युगदर्पण 09911111611, 09999777358
The previous edition of India’s Worst Journalist in 2010 on this site still remains one of the most popular posts and also a very widely reproduced one. Over the last decade or so our journalists have come to be held in the same contempt that is usually reserved for politicians. Many of them have simply forgotten the art and science of the profession and this is a serious tragedy for aspiring journalists. How they came to such a pass is a long story. The most prominent ones are not even journalists anymore; they are ‘Editorialists’ whose main job is to swing public opinion one way or another. Add to this the epidemic of ‘paidnews’ and some of our news channels and newspapers would be nothing more than Bollywood or Commercials. After all, didn’t the lateChristopher Hitchens say: “I became a journalist because one didn’t have to specialise”.
Some prominent faces from the 2010 roll of honour have dropped out. Vinod Mehta has retired from active journalism and remains Chairman of Outlook. We wish him well. Suzy Roy has moved from part-time lie-mongering to full-time Maoist-Hurriyat sympathiser. ‘Pastiwalas’ are over-joyed at the ever growing size and weight of her 50+ page essays – they’re the only ones handling them now. Prannoy Roy was also dropped. He is now more into barbeque chats than any serious attempts at journalism. Even elections don’t arouse him. But there are some new faces with the old ones. Polling for IWJ ended today and thanks to all those who voted. So here are the winners from the poll, the list of India’s Worst Journalists-2012 from the poll results. Their 2010 ranking is indicated after their name:
Large & Larger..
10. Nidhi Razdan, NDTV (New entry): She has come to prominence more for many reasons other than journalistic skills. ‘Left, right, centre’ is her signature programme and happens to be one of those mindless debates on every topic under the sun. She is proof that you can be an expert on everything with specialisation in nothing. The best part of Nidhi? Now, don’t get me wrong, she likes everything large. Whenever confounded by a brilliant argument or point by a panellist she quickly jumps to her favourite line “let’s look at the LARGER picture”. One would have thought that debates are meant to look at the finer small details. No, not with Nidhi, the larger picture is a convenient exit. Training from NDTV helps. My prediction for this debutant is that she is likely to go higher up in the list in the future.
Friendly five member
9. Kumar Ketkar (New entry): Somewhere a brief bio about Ketkar says “He started his life as an active communist worker of the Lal Nishan Paksh (Red flag party)”. Now why is that not so surprising? And that also explains Ketkar somewhat. He is also reported to be a former speech writer during elections for Congress members. Isn’t that an accomplishment any journalist would be proud of? He has been mostly a Marathi journalist and last heard he is editor of Divya Marathi. A respected veteran, he was one of the privileged Five invited to a private press meet of PM Manmohan Singh around June 2011. Ever since, it has been downhill. He achieved his right to be on this list through his performances as a panellist. What can I say? I hope being a veteran he doesn’t appear here in the future.
8. Arnab Goswami, TimesNow (2010 #3): There can be no denying that Arnab is one of the rare patriots among journalists. Almost every one wishes our judiciary could be as quick and decisive as Arnab is. Which is the reason I conferred him the title ‘Justice Arnab’. His performance on TimesNow has definitely battered ratings of NDTV and CNN-IBN. Pick up any scam, any scandal Arnab can throw the documents at you. IB, RAW, GOI have no escape – all documents and papers have to pass through Arnab. Sometime back I remarked: Most of us wake up in the morning and want Coffee or Tea! Not Arnab, he just wants ‘answers’. Such are the never-ending questions he has. Much before Arnab became a journalist the rock band U2wrote a song for him – “I still haven’t found what I’m looking for”. They were the only ones to anticipate all the unanswered questions he’d come up with. Undeniable fact is that Arnab has dropped from #3 in 2010 to #8 in 2012 on this list. That is proof of his ever-growing popularity. He can out-shout anyone in this world. Anyone, except Meenakshi Lekhi and Smriti Irani.
7. Vir Sanghvi (2010 #9): I honestly don’t have any idea whatsoever what Sanghvi currently does. I don’t even see him on any Cookery or Foodie show. He must be doing something to merit an appearance on this list again, at a higher position even. Radiagate has damaged him far more than any other journalist, which is unfortunate. He managed to surface sometime back on his home channel NDTV claiming the Radia tapes were doctored and weren’t authentic and were tested by reliable foreign forensic labs. Nobody bought that though. Sometimes, a wayward journalist, at his peak, forgets simple decency. Sanghvi will forever be haunted with two things: Radiagate and the fact that he called Narendra Modi a ‘mass-murderer’. He will regret both episodes. Had it not been for Modi ignoring his stupid outburst Vir Sanghvi would have been in prison writing a cookery book or his autobiography titled “Fine Whines!”.
No facts, please
6. Karan Thapar (2010 #4): Readers must remember that every journo looks tall in the studio but not in actual life. KT is not blessed with stature and the same goes for his journalism. One can say he has improved a bit but still retains the unwanted scowl and growl when interviewing people. Madhu Trehan in her NewsLaundry interview showed up KT for the little puppy he was. Like the ones who just need a hug and a cuddle once in a while. And if you thought you knew nothing about KT, never mind. All you have to do is hear his signature line on his promo for his show on CNN-IBN: “I don’t want to go into the facts, the facts are disputed”. LOL! Facts are disputed? You have to undo a lot of learning to understand that facts aren’t facts and can be disputed. The worst job KT did in 2011 was massaging Kapil Sibal’s brazen attempt at pre-screening content on the internet. As if that wasn’t enough he pulled out Brajesh Mishra, former NSA, out of nowhere to call serving army chief, Gen. VKSingh, the worst ever chief of army in history. My prediction: As long as he is in the business, KT will be on this list.
Wheres the smirk?
5. Vinod Sharma (New entry): For those who don’t know, Vinod Sharma is the political editor of Hindustan Times. That’s right, ‘Political’ is the key word – less of an editor and more of a politician. It’s not very hard to recognise VS on a friendly channel. He has made the ‘smirk’ more popular than child-molester DGP Rathore on television. Sharma has also been acknowledged by many political spokespersons and viewers as the most loyal spokesperson of the Congress party. No matter what the scam or what the scandal you can expect him to staunchly defend even the worst misdeeds of the Congress by blaming it on the opposition or anyone else he can lay his hands on. The one chance to get him off TV for longer periods was a Rajya Sabha ticket, when Shobana Bhartiya, his boss at HT exited, but that unfortunately didn’t happen. So we’re going to be stuck with VS for quite a while. His best moment in recent times was during the debate over Gen. VK Singh and the Tatra trucks scam. He was angry that the debate was going one way (in favour of Gen. Singh) so had to somehow twist it against the tide. In his business time VS writes a blog titled ‘Separated at birth’. I guess that refers to some Pakistani connection or maybe his journalistic independence was separated at birth. Someday we’ll find out.
He's no Egghead
4. Shekhar Gupta (2010 #10): When he appeared on the last list, a fan of Gupta wrote in stating he will email my post to SG for his response. I was wondering whether that fan objected to SG being at #10 and wanted him to be lower on the list. I guess that fan’s prayers are answered. SG has sunk further in the rankings and his Indian Express is almost on doles from the govt. His senseless programme ‘Walk the talk’ , the equivalent of ‘Koffee with Karan’ or ‘On the couch with Koel’, continues on NDTV but what sunk SG the most is his misadventure with an article on Army troop movements. In his quest to please SG’s UPA, this SG splashed a headline in IE that nearly implied the army, led by Gen.VK Singh, may have dreamt of a coup. Worse, there have been reports that the troop movement story was stale and SG’s version was actually a plant by a union minister. SG laid an egg alright but ended up with more on his face. He will forever be credited with reducing a fiercely independent newspaper like IE to a mouthpiece of a political party. His permanent place on this list is forever assured.
I washed my hands in the Hammam
3. Rajdeep Sardesai (2010 #6): Hmmm! The guy is making progress alright. I have always maintained there are two Rajdeeps – One on TV and one off it. Whenever he is off TV his conscience strikes and one can hear a sane person, sometimes profound, sometimes emotional. But his character loses focus in front of the camera. Recently, he lamented on Twitter about being abused as a’Muslim whore and a Motherf$#!#*’. Bad, but the kind of abuse of journalistic ethics that Rajdeep has frequently allowed under his watch is far more serious. He has even given the media the right to ‘conduct hearings’ against personalities. While he wonders about ‘image makeovers’ for others, there is no way he can ever get past the Cash4Votes bungling or the terribly biased reporting on Gujarat riots. His 2007 conduct of an HT Summit which featured a key speaker reflects a character of pathetically low moral values and journalistic ethics. And to top that he defended the tainted Radiagate journalists and was rightly ‘slapped’ by his own community. Death of decent journalism owes a small debt to him. He has rightly earned the nick name ‘Hammamboy’!
If it's Friday, it must be...
2. Sagarika Ghose (2010 #2): Ms. Cacofonixstays where she was: at No.2. You can’t fault Sagarika for not trying hard enough to be India’s worst journalist. She has made every effort in the recent past to get to #1.Journalism gives her a bad name. For her truly pathetic and fraudulent ‘live’ show with SriSri she would have been sacked from any TV channel in the world. That in itself is a reflection of the ethics and morals practiced at CNN-IBN by her and her boss Rajdeep Sardesai. You can imagine the skulduggery behind all other programmes and debates. And if that wasn’t enough she misses no chance to prove she is a ‘journalistic bimbo’ by mindless tweets on the social network. Be it about ‘ugly Indian males’, or Orange being a colour in our national flag or sending out a Good Friday greeting and withdrawing it she is truly the court-jester of Indian journalism. What can I say? Better luck next time!
Me, Myself & I
1. Barkha Dutt (2010 #1): For the second time in a row Barkha retains her position as India’s worst journalist in the poll, by a whopping margin. The only road to redemption is apologising for past blunders. While she and another one have been vocal in demanding apologies and expressions of remorse from public figures the same standard doesn’t seem to apply to her. No matter what she does the taint of Radiagate and many other indiscretions are unlikely to disappear. The accusations of causing deaths in Kargil or in 26/11 are also going to linger. She is probably the only news celeb on TV that has a ‘wardrobe sponsor’. All the image makeovers may not help much. Most of us have held Rahul Gandhi for the Congress’ UP election disaster but Barkha and NDTV must be credited with the disaster too. No one has singularly promoted RG and his cause and almost turned him into India’s saviour till the engine got derailed. Her penchant for Pakistani politics and politicians is another thing that disgusts many viewers. In the meantime her language keeps getting better and better. In a recent tweet she responded to sarcasm with: “… ‘Nazi Dogs’ .. if ever language betrayed desperation of loser, it is here…” Losers or not, with over 70% of the votes polled, Barkha is the absolute winner here. Cheers!
So there you are. Let’s also not forget that are many journalists who now increasingly seem to be anti-nationals. Their ties to Ghulam Nabi Fai aren’t even being investigated by the govt. Industry leaders usually raise the standards of performance of the industry as a whole. The opposite seems to be true in the media. Systematically, many of India’s journalists have brought the profession to rock bottom over the years. I continue to maintain, they are the greatest threat to our democracy.
Note: The poll results are at the Top right of this page
Record shows a Good Global Traffic on all my blogs, but no comments since long. How can we give you Good Posts of your Likings without it, so you get disappointed. Pl. do comment each time, you visit the Blog. Tilak.
विश्व के 50 से अधिक देशों के पाठकों का आवागमन तो दिखता है, पाठक संख्या भी 5000 हो गई किन्तु आपकी टिप्पणी न होने से हम आपकी रूचि से अवगत नहीं हो पाते, अच्छी सामग्री की कमी से आपको निराशा न हो अत: टिप्पणी अवश्य करें.
देश की मिटटी की सुगंध, भारतचौपाल! तिलक 9911111611 ,9654675533 .
212 न्यू अशोक नगर (म.)भाजपा, निकी सिंह
213 कल्याण पुरी (अनु.जा.) भाजपा, राज कुमार
214 खिचड़ी पुर (सा.) निर्द., विनोद कुमार बिन्नी
215 कोंडली (म.)बसपा, प्रियंका गौतम
216 घरोली (सा.) कांग्रेस, राजीव कुमार
217 विनोद नगर (म.)भाजपा, सरला चौधरी 218 मंडावली (अनु.जा.म.) भाजपा, सुदेशना
219 मयूर विहार फे.-II (सा.) भाजपा, देवेन्द्र कुमार
220 पटपड़ गंज (म.) भाजपा, संध्या वर्मा
221 किशन कुञ्ज (सा.) भाजपा, बी.बी. त्यागी
222 लक्ष्मी नगर (म.) भाजपा, आशा सिंह 223 शकरपुर (सा.) भाजपा, सुशील उपाध्याय 224 पांडव नगर (म.) भाजपा, गुप्ता लता
225 आनंद विहार (सा.) भाजपा, महिंद्र कुमार आहूजा
226 विश्वाश नगर (अनु.जा.) कांग्रेस, रतन सिंह
227 आई.पी. एक्सटेंशन (म.) कांग्रेस, गीता शर्मा
228 प्रीत विहार (सा.) कांग्रेस, गुरुचरण सिंह
229 कृष्ण नगर (म.) भाजपा, सुश्री. कल्पना देवी जैन
230 गीता कालोनी (सा.) निर्द., बंसी लाल
231 घोंडली (म.) कांग्रेस, सुश्री. इशरत जहाँ
232 अनारकली (सा.) भाजपा, जय गोपाल
233 धरम पुरा (अनु.जा.म.) कांग्रेस, तुलशी
234 गाँधी नगर (म.) कांग्रेस, अंजना शर्मा
235 आजाद नगर (सा.) भाजपा, जितेन्द्र
236 रघुबर पूरा (म.) कांग्रेस, वरयाम कौर
237 शाहदरा (अनु.जा.) भाजपा, बलबीर सिंह
238 झिलमिल (सा.) भाजपा, जितेन्द्र सिंह शन्टी
239 विवेक विहार (म.) निर्द., प्रीती
240 दिलशाद कालोनी (सा.) भाजपा, राम नारायण दूबे
241 दिलशाद गर्दन (म.) भाजपा, स्वाति गुप्ता
242 न्यू सीमापुरी (सा.) भाजपा, सुनील कुमार झा
243 नन्द नगरी (अनु.जा.म.) कांग्रेस, रिंकू
244 सुंदर नगरी (म.) भाजपा, कमलेश
245 दुर्गा पुरी (अनु.जा.) कांग्रेस, अनिल गौतम
246 अशोक नगर (सा.) भाजपा, संजय सुरजन 247 राम नगर (म.)भाजपा, सुषमा शर्मा